Uncategorized

More Jobs Are Showing Up on LinkedIn. So Why Does the Jobs Report Look So Gloomy?

More Jobs Are Showing Up on LinkedIn. So Why Does the Jobs Report Look So Gloomy?

If you spend any amount of time on LinkedIn lately, you may have noticed something interesting:

There seem to be a lot more jobs being posted.

As a recruiter, I’m seeing it too. More openings. More companies talking about hiring. More positions showing up in our feeds.

So why does the national jobs report sound so gloomy?

The latest numbers certainly aren’t exciting. The U.S. added just 29,000 jobs in September, while unemployment stood at 4.2%. Even more telling, job growth has averaged only about 45,000 per month over the past year.

At first glance, that doesn’t seem to match what many of us are seeing on LinkedIn.

But here’s the key:

A Job Posting Is Not the Same Thing as a Hire

Companies can post jobs long before they actually fill them.

Some organizations are hiring, but doing so much more cautiously. They may interview more candidates, take longer to make decisions, delay approvals, change the requirements halfway through the process, or decide not to fill the position at all.

In other words, there can be plenty of hiring activity without a lot of actual hiring.

LinkedIn’s own data tells an interesting story. U.S. hiring increased 1.9% from July to August, and hiring accelerated in 15 of the 20 industries LinkedIn tracks.

That’s encouraging.

But zoom out, and hiring was still 6.5% lower than a year earlier and roughly 25% below its pre-pandemic pace.

So both things can be true:

Companies are posting jobs.

And the overall labor market can still be sluggish.

Employers May Be Starting to Test the Waters

I think we’re also seeing companies that have been sitting on the sidelines begin to move again.

For the last couple of years, many employers have been hesitant to add headcount. Economic uncertainty, interest rates, inflation, technology changes, AI, and questions about future demand have all contributed to a “wait and see” approach.

Eventually, companies can’t wait forever.

People retire. Employees leave. Business grows. Projects get approved. Skills change. Companies discover that doing more with less eventually becomes simply doing less with less.

That creates hiring needs — even in a slow economy.

The Labor Market Isn’t One Labor Market

Another reason the headlines can be misleading is that there really isn’t one national job market.

There are thousands of smaller ones.

The market for an engineer in Pittsburgh can look very different from the market for an accountant in Houston or a salesperson in Atlanta.

The same is true across industries.

LinkedIn recently reported year-over-year hiring gains in areas including construction, manufacturing, and technology/information/media, while other sectors remained considerably weaker.

If you’re working in recruiting every day, you may see pockets of activity well before they become obvious in the national numbers.

Could Job Postings Be a Leading Indicator?

This is the part I’m watching closely.

The national employment report tells us primarily about jobs that have already been created.

Job postings tell us something about what employers may be planning to do next.

That doesn’t mean every LinkedIn posting will become a hire. It won’t.

But if we’re beginning to see a sustained increase in legitimate openings across companies and industries, it could be an early sign that employers are becoming more confident about hiring.

And after a long period of cautious hiring, that would be welcome news.

What Does This Mean for Job Seekers?

Don’t let a gloomy national headline convince you that nobody is hiring.

Companies are hiring.

But today’s market requires more patience, more networking, and more persistence than it did a few years ago. Employers can afford to be selective, and hiring processes are often taking longer.

The opportunity is there. It just may take more work to find it.

And for employers, there’s another side to this equation: If more companies begin hiring at the same time, the competition for good people can change very quickly.

The companies that wait until everyone agrees the job market is “good again” may find themselves competing for the same talent.

The employment report tells us where the labor market has been.

Job postings may be giving us a glimpse of where it’s going.

I’m curious what others are seeing.

Are you noticing more job postings on LinkedIn? And more importantly, are you seeing companies actually hiring?

Share this Blog Posting:

Why Does The Job Report Look So Gloomy?